Dr. Christian Fuchs
Senior Analyst Data & Analytics
Dr. Christian Fuchs is Senior Analyst and Head of Data & Analytics Research at BARC.
Compare 13 software vendors at a glance using BARC Score Integrated Planning & Analytics for the German-speaking region.
To purchase the BARC Score, please contact us.
Planning, budgeting and forecasting are important elements of corporate management to align operational business with strategic corporate objectives. In recent years, the dynamics of markets and competition have increased rapidly and many companies are struggling to keep pace. In particular, corporate planning and forecasting are more essential than ever to cope with increasing dynamics. Well-founded decisions based on current forecasts and data analytics, the efficient evaluation of possible future developments in scenarios and simulations as well as the automation of processes and the relief of planners are becoming massively more important. However, successful corporate performance management (CPM) requires comprehensive planning and forecasting, analytics and business intelligence (BI) functionality.
This BARC Score focuses on the market for integrated planning and analytics (IP&A) products and portfolios. The combination of these topics is of high importance for a growing number of companies. Based on countless data points from various BARC surveys and many analyst interactions, vendors are rated on a variety of criteria, ranging from portfolio capabilities and architecture to sales and marketing strategy, financial performance and customer feedback.
To be considered for inclusion in this BARC Score, products must align with BARC’s definition of integrated planning & analytics (IP&A). Moreover, there are two separate categories of inclusion criteria: the first is associated with a vendor’s product capabilities and portfolios and the other is linked to the market presence and financial results relating to those products.
Functionality for planning (including write-back of planning data to a central database and other advanced planning features such as workflows, forecasting and simulation) is the ‘entrance ticket’ to be evaluated in this BARC Score. Moreover, a vendor has to supply additional functionality for at least three out of four analytics technologies from the following list in a solution not merely focused on one industry or use case:
In addition, a vendor must have at least 250 productive customers and generate a minimum of 20-25 million EUR in revenue per year (software revenue) with the evaluated product set in this BARC Score. Furthermore, the product set must have a significant number of implementations and license or subscription revenues in the DACH region (Germany, Austria and Switzerland).
There is no differentiation between on-premises offerings and cloud-based product sets.
Vendor | Product name |
---|---|
Anaplan | Anaplan |
Board International | Board |
Corporate Planning | Corporate Planner |
IBM |
IBM Planning Analytics IBM Cognos Analytics IBM Controller |
Infor |
Infor EPM Infor Birst |
insightsoftware |
Bizview Fiplana IDL |
Jedox | Jedox |
OneStream, Inc. | OneStream |
Oracle |
Oracle Cloud EPM Oracle Hyperion EPM Oracle Analytics Cloud Oracle Analytics Server |
SAP |
SAP Analytics Cloud SAP Business Planning & Consolidation SAP BusinessObjects BI SAP S/4HANA Finance for Group Reporting |
Unit4 | Unit4 FP&A |
Wolters Kluwer I CCH Tagetik | CCH Tagetik |
Workday |
Workday Adaptive Planning Workday Financial Management Workday Prism Analytics |
Software providers are evaluated on two dimensions, ‘Portfolio Capabilities’ and ‘Market Execution’, each representing an axis on the chart.
In addition to BARC’s analyst opinion, user experience also plays an important role.
Our BARC Score IP&A is based on the world’s largest surveys of planning and BI & analytics software usage, the BI & Analytics Survey and the Planning Survey, which ask companies each year about their satisfaction with software vendors and solutions.
Detailed analyst knowledge and comprehensive survey results are summarized in the BARC Score report and chart. The chart provides a clear view of each vendor’s market position and portfolio.